审稿意见回复模板(Response to reviewer)

审稿人通常会有以下几类问题,针对不同问题我们可以有不同的回答模板。

切记:一定展现出诚意,虚心回答,point by point,不要刻意回避某些问题。

补充实验:

这类问题通常都很复杂,切忌回避问题。真的要做到点对点回答。你所要回避的问题审稿人都能发现。所以即使我们现有条件解决不了,我们也要向审稿人承认。不要自欺欺人。做科研还是要严谨,实在不行拒稿就换一家期刊。

补充实验符合理论预期

  1. Thank you for suggesting the addition of experimental data. We have conducted the experiments as advised, and the results indeed align with the theoretical expectations.
  2. Thank you for............We appreciate your recommendation to include supplementary experiments. The results obtained are in line with the theoretical predictions, confirming our initial hypothesis.
  3. Thank you for............Following your suggestion, we have carried out additional experiments. The results obtained are consistent with the theoretical framework, supporting our conclusions.
  4. Thank you for............We have conducted the recommended experiments, and the results obtained confirm the anticipated outcomes based on the theoretical assumptions. Thank you for guiding us in this direction.
  5. Thank you for............Upon conducting the supplementary experiments as suggested, we found that the results align closely with the theoretical expectations. Your advice proved to be invaluable in strengthening our research.
  6. Thank you for emphasizing the importance of additional experiments. The results obtained are in accordance with the theoretical predictions, further solidifying the validity of our findings.
  7. Thank you for............We have taken your feedback into consideration and conducted the recommended experiments. The results obtained match the theoretical expectations outlined in the paper, providing robust support for our arguments.
  8. Thank you for............The additional experiments performed as per your suggestion have yielded results that are in line with the theoretical predictions. Thank you for prompting us to further validate our findings through experimentation.
  9. Thank you for............Based on your recommendation, we have carried out supplementary experiments. The results obtained are consistent with the theoretical framework proposed in the paper, reinforcing the validity of our research.
  10. Thank you for............We have followed your advice and conducted the supplementary experiments. The results obtained support the theoretical expectations outlined in our study. Your guidance has been instrumental in enhancing the rigor of our research.

转载自:公众号【理论学习计算未来】,作者jinghan